Lifetime Refurbishment
Yes, we do mean unlimited. At American Hat Makers we want to make sure you love your hat, because it’s going to last a lifetime.
So if your hat is the wrong size or you just don’t love the style for any reason, then you can send it back for an exchange free of charge. That’s free shipping back to us and free shipping back to you.
Not sure about your fit? Call us! A real person and expert hat fitter will be on the other side of the line to answer any questions about fit, exchanges, style or returns 831-722-3324. Or click here: Hat Sizes for our full guide.
*Please note that any Sale items are final sale and not eligible for unlimited free exchanges.*
For full details and FAQs, click here to learn more or process an exchange.
American Hat Makers headwear is built to last a lifetime, so we want you to take your time falling in love with your new favorite hat.
Take 90-days to make sure your hat is the perfect fit and the perfect style. If for whatever reason you don’t love your hat and want to return it, we make it as easy as possible.
Just pay a small shipping and restocking fee of $9.81 (which will be automatically deducted from your refund amount), send back your hat, and you’re good to go.
Not sure about your fit? Call us! A real person and expert hat fitter will be on the other side of the line to answer any questions about fit, exchanges, style or returns 831-722-3324.
For full details and FAQs, click here to learn more or process a return.
Our Hats Have Been Seen On
- Top Grade Materials - Manufactured to the highest standard, our materials are put through rigorous testing to ensure their quality and then expertly crafted into one of our timeless designs. Our leather is supple, our felt is durable, and our straw tightly woven.
- Hats That Hold Their Shape - All American Hat Makers hats are guaranteed to hold their shape, and will not stretch or shrink with everyday wear. This mens leather cowboy hat can be restored even if it gets warped. Purchasing our lifetime refurbishment at checkout will guarantee that if your hat is accidentally damaged you can send it back to us for a painless and timely repair.
- They Fit! - Our hats fit! It sounds simple enough but with so many shapes and sizes of heads out there it can be a challenge. To overcome this obstacle we’ve designed several fit adjustment systems, all of which remain hidden behind the sweatband to keep your hat looking sharp from all angles. Check out more here.
Every one of our hats come with a 50 year guarantee. That means that if your hat fails in any way to meet your standards due to our craftsmanship then we’ll repair or replace your hat free of charge. So if your hat starts unraveling in 50 years, we’ll take it back and make it right.
Call us anytime! We don’t want to hide behind our website. We’re real people with a deep love and understanding for all of our hats; so any questions you have we’ll be ready to answer them. Need help picking out a hat? We can do that too! Not only can we help you with any questions or concerns you’re having, we can also help you find the perfect hat for your face shape and lifestyle.
We’re available 9am-5pm PST - give us a call at 831-722-3324.
We dislike returns just as much as the next person, so we’ve vowed to ALWAYS make returns and exchanges painless. If you don’t like your hat, if it doesn’t fit, or you want a different one - we’ll help you. Read our full return and exchange policy here.
Our Hats Have Been Seen In
Reviews
- Fit
- Quality
- Appearance
- Value
- Materials
- EHEliza H.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars4 days agoCoyote-Mens Black Bongara Straw Cattlemen Crown Hat-LG
Coyote-Mens Black Bongara Straw Cattlemen Crown Hat-LG bought it as a early Father's Day gift for my boyfriend it was one of the best choices I've made after shopping around. The quality, the style, the fit are perfect. It was delivered in a timely manner well packed no damage packaged. My bf loved it. I will definitely shop here again but next time for me!! Thanks America Hat Makers you did not disappoint 👏
AHAmerican Hat Makers3 days agoThank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re thrilled to hear the Coyote Men’s Black Bongara Straw Cattlemen Crown Hat was the perfect gift and that everything from the quality to the fit and delivery met your expectations.
It’s especially wonderful to hear your boyfriend loved it—and we’re honored you’d shop with us again (next time for yourself too!). We truly appreciate your support and kind words, and we look forward to helping you again soon.
- YWYolanda W.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars4 days agoMy Liberty Straw Hat women’s
Love my women’s Liberty straw hat ! Had plenty of compliments worn to our Elizabeth Stampede 2026 ! Looking forward to wearing in celebrating our 250th birthday of the USA!
AHAmerican Hat Makers3 days agoWe’re really glad you’re enjoying your Liberty Straw Hat and even better that it’s getting plenty of compliments at the Elizabeth Stampede. Sounds like it was the perfect pick for the occasion. And it’s great to hear it’ll be part of your 250th celebration plans too—what a fun way to wear it!
Appreciate you taking the time to leave a review and share the photo with us.
- CQCoralie Q.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars6 days agoOutstanding!!!
Beautiful, soft, well made!! Perfect size. Love it!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers4 days agoThank you so much—we really appreciate the kind words! We’re glad to hear the hat is a perfect fit and that you’re loving it.
- DSDebbie S.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 week agoLove it!
The hat is beautiful and is truly representative of how it was depicted online. The site is informative on how to measure to ensure a great fit. I also appreciated the hat care pamphlet I received with my carefully packed order. Even though I’m from Texas, this was my first “real” cowboy hat and I was hesitant about ordering online - not anymore! I’ll be ordering another in the near future!
AHAmerican Hat Makers4 days agoThank you so much for sharing this—we really appreciate it. We’re glad the sizing guide, care information, and packaging helped make your first cowboy hat experience a great one. It means a lot to hear it lived up to what you saw online, and we look forward to helping you with your next hat soon.
- VPVlad P.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 week ago"Unforgiven" - Unmatched Style!!
I own many wide brim leather and Western hats ... I wasn't looking for another ... but American Hat Makers are right down here in Texas, so when FB showed me their ad, I figured I'd do the right friendly Texas thing and look through their site ... very nice hats ... THEN ... I saw this "Unforgiven" model and was STOPPED in my tracks. Quickly I Googled a photo of Clint Eastwood from the movie (hadn't seen it in over 30 years), and sure enough - it has that "Unforgiven" look alright! Well who doesn't want to to look like Clint???? *LOL* Anyway - just got it this week - I must say it now is the HIGHEST QUALITY leather hat I own, with beautiful lining, thick sturdy Bison Leather - and MAN DOES IT LOOK GOOD! As soon as I put it on my wife complimented me! Its my #1 favorite hat now!!! THANK YOU!!!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 week agoThank you so much for this amazing review—we really appreciate you taking the time to share it!
We’re thrilled to hear the “Unforgiven” hat stood out to you and became your new favorite. Sounds like it made a great first impression at home too—always a good sign when the wife approves right away!
We also love hearing your feedback on the bison leather and lining. That’s exactly the level of quality we aim for, so it means a lot to know it’s coming through.
Thanks again for your support and for choosing us—we’re glad to have you in the family!
- SSStephen S.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoNewest
Fits well. Material stiffer than expected but very ice.
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 weeks agoThanks for sharing your feedback! We’re glad to hear it fits well, and we appreciate your note about the material feeling a bit stiffer than expected. We’ll be sure to pass that along.
- PLPhillip L.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoExcellent
Good investment for what life can throw your hats way.
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 weeks agoThanks for the feedback — really glad to hear you’re happy with it and that it’s holding up well for you.
- JGJerry G. B.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoFirst time purchase
First time purchase
Great experience
Love the look and feel
Can’t wait to wear it outside
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 weeks agoThanks so much for the kind feedback — we really appreciate it!
We’re glad to hear you love the look and feel of your new hat. Enjoy wearing it out!
- RBRobert B.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoMy first Fedora - this thing is incredible!
This Panama-style Fedora is amazing. The craftsmanship and materials are impeccable, and I love the velcro sizer band! Initially I purchased a medium based on the measurements I took, but ended up returning it for a large. The exchange process was not only easy, but incredibly fast! I typically wear baseball caps, but figured I would take a chance on a more upscale look, and I couldn't be happier. The venting in the hat provides an unexpected cooling while walking that I just don't get when wearing a baseball cap. I can't wait to purchase another!
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 weeks agoWe’re glad to hear the exchange process went smoothly and that the large ended up being the right fit for you. It’s great to know the ventilation, sizer system, and overall feel are working so well, especially as you transition from baseball caps to a more elevated style.
We truly appreciate your support, and we look forward to helping you find your next hat when you’re ready!
- KTKip T.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoOver 30 years of hats for me
Trained and showed horses most of my adult life… I lost 2 American Hats (beaver show hats) about 20 years ago. I had them cleaned and reshaped many times after being tortured in the pasture working cows, hauling hay, or just riding! I would still be wearing them for f they hadn’t been stolen out of my truck! Just got another straw and a lifetime refurbish (well worth the money) - will get another winter hat this fall!!
Great company and great service!!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 weeks agoIt’s great to hear the hats have held up through so many years of hard use out in the field, and we’re glad the straw and lifetime refurbish service are working well for you. Losing those originals the way you did must’ve been frustrating, but we’re honored you’ve come back for another.
We truly appreciate your long support and look forward to helping you with that winter hat this fall!