El Dorado Buffalo Nickel | Mens Leather Top Hat with Buffalo Nickel Hat Band
Yes, we do mean unlimited. At American Hat Makers we want to make sure you love your hat, because it’s going to last a lifetime.
So if your hat is the wrong size or you just don’t love the style for any reason, then you can send it back for an exchange free of charge. That’s free shipping back to us and free shipping back to you.
Not sure about your fit? Call us! A real person and expert hat fitter will be on the other side of the line to answer any questions about fit, exchanges, style or returns 831-722-3324. Or click here: Hat Sizes for our full guide.
*Please note that any Sale items are final sale and not eligible for unlimited free exchanges.*
For full details and FAQs, click here to learn more or process an exchange.
American Hat Makers headwear is built to last a lifetime, so we want you to take your time falling in love with your new favorite hat.
Take 90-days to make sure your hat is the perfect fit and the perfect style. If for whatever reason you don’t love your hat and want to return it, we make it as easy as possible.
Just pay a small shipping and restocking fee of $9.81 (which will be automatically deducted from your refund amount), send back your hat, and you’re good to go.
Not sure about your fit? Call us! A real person and expert hat fitter will be on the other side of the line to answer any questions about fit, exchanges, style or returns 831-722-3324.
For full details and FAQs, click here to learn more or process a return.
Our Hats Have Been Seen On
- Top Grade Materials - Manufactured to the highest standard, our materials are put through rigorous testing to ensure their quality and then expertly crafted into one of our timeless designs. Our leather is supple, our felt is durable, and our straw tightly woven.
- Hats That Hold Their Shape - All American Hat Makers hats are guaranteed to hold their shape, and will not stretch or shrink with everyday wear. This mens leather cowboy hat can be restored even if it gets warped. Purchasing our lifetime refurbishment at checkout will guarantee that if your hat is accidentally damaged you can send it back to us for a painless and timely repair.
- They Fit! - Our hats fit! It sounds simple enough but with so many shapes and sizes of heads out there it can be a challenge. To overcome this obstacle we’ve designed several fit adjustment systems, all of which remain hidden behind the sweatband to keep your hat looking sharp from all angles. Check out more here.
Every one of our hats come with a 50 year guarantee. That means that if your hat fails in any way to meet your standards due to our craftsmanship then we’ll repair or replace your hat free of charge. So if your hat starts unraveling in 50 years, we’ll take it back and make it right.
Call us anytime! We don’t want to hide behind our website. We’re real people with a deep love and understanding for all of our hats; so any questions you have we’ll be ready to answer them. Need help picking out a hat? We can do that too! Not only can we help you with any questions or concerns you’re having, we can also help you find the perfect hat for your face shape and lifestyle.
We’re available 9am-5pm PST - give us a call at 831-722-3324.
We dislike returns just as much as the next person, so we’ve vowed to ALWAYS make returns and exchanges painless. If you don’t like your hat, if it doesn’t fit, or you want a different one - we’ll help you. Read our full return and exchange policy here.
Our Hats Have Been Seen In
Hat Sizing Chart
Standard Sizing Chart
Centimeters
Inches
| Our Size | Your Head Measurement | Standard Hat Size | |
|---|---|---|---|
| OS | One Size Fits Most | One Size Fits Most | - |
| XS | 20" - 20 7⁄8" | 52cm - 53cm | 6 1⁄2 |
| SM | 21" - 21 7⁄8" | 54cm - 55cm | 6 7⁄8 |
| MD | 22" - 22 3⁄4" | 56cm - 57cm | 7 1/8 |
| LG | 22 7⁄8" - 23 1⁄2" | 58cm - 59cm | 7 3⁄8 |
| XL | 23 5⁄8" - 24 1⁄4" | 60cm - 61cm | 7 5⁄8 |
| 2X | 24 3⁄8" - 24 7⁄8" | 62cm - 63cm | 7 7⁄8 |
| 3X | 25" - 25 5⁄8" | 64cm - 65cm | 8 1⁄8 |
How to Measure Your Head
- Grab a soft measuring tape or a piece of string (like twine or a shoelace) and a ruler or measuring tool
- Wrap a soft tape or string around your head to measure about 1/4 to 1/2 inch above your ear and about 3/4 to an 1" inch above your brow line (see image)
- Mark the tape or your string, where it intersects, with your finger.
- Record your measurement in inches or centimeters (centimeters is often more accurate)
- If you're using a string, run it along side the ruler as many times as necessary to get a complete measurement
- MEASURE AGAIN!
- Always measure more than once until you get the same number twice
- Find your size in the chart for the perfect fit
Flexfit Sizing Chart
Centimeters
Inches
| Our Size | Your Head Measurement | |
|---|---|---|
| S/M | 22 1/8" - 22 3/4" | 55cm - 57cm |
| L/XL | 22 7/8" - 23 5/8" | 58cm - 60cm |
Reviews
- SCSir C.Rated 5 out of 5 stars2 days agoBest Hat EVER!!!
I've had this hat for years and still get compliments and offers to purchase it!!! Fits as advertised !!! I've bought several hats from this company and all were packed well and I use the boxes to store them !!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers20 seconds agoSir C., thank you for that wonderful 5-star review! It warms our hearts to hear how our El Dorado Buffalo Nickel has been turning heads and sparking conversations for years. We're mighty pleased knowing you're out there enjoying your collection of our hats, and your kind words about our packaging have us grinning from ear to ear. It's loyal partners like you that make what we do feel less like business and more like family! 🤠
- DJDavid J.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 month agoBuy it
If you are thinking about buying this hat just buy it. This hat is awesome! I can tell this hat was manufactured by people who care about the product they put out. If you want to be dripping with rizz as the kids say, then you NEED this hat!
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 month agoThank you, David, for the exceptional 5-star review! We're delighted by your enthusiastic endorsement of the El Dorado Buffalo Nickel Top Hat and your recognition of the craftsmanship that goes into each piece. Your modern take on the hat's style impact - "dripping with rizz" - perfectly captures how our traditional designs continue to make bold statements in contemporary fashion. We're truly proud that the dedication and care we put into manufacturing each hat shines through so clearly in the final product you received.
- BRBjarne R.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars3 months agoCool hat
I have been wanting to get this hat for about 2 years and finally got one. I’m so satisfied for it.
AHAmerican Hat Makers3 months agoBjarne, we're overjoyed by your fantastic 5-star review! Thank you for your patience and loyalty - it brings us immense joy to hear that the hat you've coveted for so long has exceeded your expectations. We're delighted to have played a part in elevating your overall hat-wearing experience with a piece that embodies timeless sophistication and complements your unique style. We can't wait to continue impressing you with outstanding pieces that will undoubtedly garner similar satisfaction for years to come.
- VMVaughn M.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars8 months agoLove The Hat!!!!
This is my third hat from American Hat Makers. Their products are high quality. This top hat is by far my favourite. I did find the sizing a little bit different from my previous purchases. While all the hats are theoretically the same size the top hat seems to fit quite a bit bigger.
AHAmerican Hat Makers8 months agoAwesome Vaughn! We're thrilled to hear you love your new top hat. Thank you for your loyalty and the 5 STARS! Our sizing can vary slightly between hat styles due to differences in materials and construction. We're happy to exchange for a different size to ensure the perfect fit. Thank you for choosing American Hat Makers!
- RMRick M.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 year agoThe Best
Excellent Top Hat! Always getting "I love that hat"!..."Great Hat!"...And I always tell them where to get one...
This company knows how to treat customers and stand behind their product 100%.
The Best
🎩
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 year agoYou look absolutely amazing! Thank you for sharing a snapshot of your visit! Your smile says it all. We're delighted that you had a wonderful experience, and we look forward to welcoming you back.
- RRRichard R.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 year agoAwesome Hat
I absolutely love this hat. The workmanship is excellent. It fits very well. This is my second hat from you guys. And it won't be the last.
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 year agoThank you for your review. We are happy to learn that you loved your new hat and seeing your photo brings a big smile to our faces! We're delighted that you enjoyed your time with us and appreciate you sharing this memory with us and others.
- TKThomas K.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 year agoAwesome hat!!
Beautiful workmanship and fits perfectly. Love it and had many rave reviews on it. Thank you so much!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 year agoThank you, Thomas! The hat looks great on you.
- RMRick M.Verified ReviewerRated 5 out of 5 stars1 year agoOutstanding
I had one of these and sold it to a gentleman who would not take no for an answer...purchasing another to replace it!
Wonderful hat!
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 year agoThanks, Rick! We're glad that you were able to buy a new one for you.
- JSJeremy S.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 years agoPerfect Hat
The hat fits my head perfectly and I received tons of compliments. Initial quality and super high. One of the best purchases I've made in ages.
AHAmerican Hat Makers1 year agoThanks, Jeremy! Your review means a lot to us and it helps spread the word about our business to other customers like you!
- CJCorey J.Verified BuyerRated 5 out of 5 stars2 years agoTHE BEST EVER NOT MADE IN CHINA🤠👌🏽👏
This Hat is where it's At!!! A must Get for the Classic Alpha !! I get bombarded with compliments when I'm stepping out! This Hat exhibits class,Flare and Attitude! I love American Hat Makers for making the Best Hats ever not made in China!!!
AHAmerican Hat Makers2 years agoThanks, Corey! Great to hear that everyone loves the El Dorado!